Friend #7 : The Friend You Learn From (The Mind-Opener)

Nothing says warmth and comfort like a fireplace scene on a holiday TV show. One of my favorite scenes is in the Saturday Night Live sketch called, “Best Christmas Ever.” In this one, Matt Damon and Cecily Strong play a happy couple, snuggling by the fire, reflecting on the Christmas Day from hell. They did their best to reframe a rough day and focus on the good in it. If you can relate to that, I empathize.

Friendship brings joys and challenges. Friends may comfort or confront us. If it’s done right, we’ll be better for it. This is what Proverbs 17:17 means when it says, “As iron sharpens iron, so one friend sharpens another” (New Living Translation).



Today I want to offer help for your holiday gatherings. Perhaps you may see or be Vital Friend #7 — the friend who helps you learn and grow, The Mind Opener.

See The Mind-Opener

In Vital Friends: Eight Friends You Can’t Live Without, Tom Rath says that the Mind Opener can…


  • Expand your horizons
  • Expose you to new ideas, cultures, and opportunities
  • Shed light on blind spots and gaps in your thinking
  • Challenge you to think in innovative ways and create positive change
  • Ask hard questions
  • Make you think outside the box (no judgment)
  • Challenge conventional wisdom and shake up the status quo



Do you have a Mind Opener friend or two? Can you name them? If not, beware. Don’t insulate yourself from honest feedback or silence the corrective voice.

Free the Mind Opener

When we were raising our boys, my sweet Bonnie and I would sometimes scuffle. When that happened, my boys would frequently take their mother’s side. On one such occasion, words were spoken and Bonnie got up and left the room.The boys looked down, then looked up at me. “What?” I asked. “Why am I always the one who has to apologize?” After a moment, one of them said, “Because you’re always the one who says something wrong.” Punk kids.


My boys were inviting me to consider an alternative point of view. Those of us in authority should listen now and then. We should stay humble, lest we play the fool like King Ahab. He complained about the prophet Micaiah, saying, “I hate him because he never prophesies anything good about me, but always bad” (1 Kings 22:8).


Mike Sares describes certain congregants as, “Brother Brillo Pad and Sister Sandpaper.” They can be abrasive and rub us the wrong way, but they challenge us to be better. So long as they speak to us with love and respect, we should let them give us input.



But since that’s not always the case, we may find it elusive to experience the best Thanksgiving ever. I have a suggestion that might help with that. 

Your Thanksgiving Table

I know how hard the holidays can be right now.


Many of us are missing loved ones who are far away or gone forever. We may also sit across the table from folks who see the world differently than we do. We may love one another dearly, yet disagree passionately. What do we do when we see things differently? In times like these, we need the Mind Opener more than ever.


I suggest we consider one of the great Mind Openers of the 20th century, Nelson Mandela. As you may recall, Mandela spent 27 years in South African prisons for standing against racism and social inequities. Yet he said, “I never lose. I either win or I learn.”


You may not be able to change anyone’s mind this holiday season. But maybe that’s not the assignment we have anyway. Maybe we are there to have our own minds opened and to listen with a sincere and humble goal — to learn.



Our holiday tables would become more gracious and transformational if we all took a page from this towering figure, this heroic Mind Opener.

Takeaways…

  1. Do you have friends or family members who help you consider other points of view?
  2. Are you humble enough to listen and learn?
  3. Do you help others consider alternative views or make tense situations worse?


Please leave a comment in the box below.


PS I am so grateful for the urban Christian leaders we have been able to support and strengthen in 2021. Next week, please keep an eye on your Inbox for a special Update from me.

By Steve Garcia July 12, 2025
When Exhaustion Turns Ugly
By Steve Garcia April 19, 2025
Wouldn’t it be nice if Christians were always nice? If we always got along? But if you’ve been around for a while, you know that’s not always the case. Seasoned veterans of ministry can tell war stories about life on the mission field, in church staffs, and throughout congregational life. I once heard Howard Hendricks say: “To dwell above with the saints we love,
 O that will be glory;
 but to dwell below with the saints I know —
well, that’s a different story.” That quote shows you the value of seasoned saints — they’ve seen some things. One of those saints in my life is my mentor and friend, Les Avery. Les once told me: “Steve, there are three kinds of problems you’ll encounter in church life: management problems, relationship problems, and spiritual problems.
You get in trouble when you try to solve one kind of problem with a different kind of solution.” That insight has stuck with me for decades. And it’s never been more relevant. The 3 Kinds of Problems Here’s a breakdown of Les’s framework: 🛠️ Management Problems These are about systems or logistics. Think: Dirty dishes left in the church kitchen Double-booked rooms Communication breakdowns They’re practical, solvable — if you treat them that way. 🤝 Relationship Problems These arise when: Blind spots go unchecked Trust is broken Tensions rise People stop listening Relational issues need relational repair, not just better policies. 🙏 Spiritual Problems These emerge when we miss the mark on a heart level — when we: Drift from the Jesus way of relating Compromise integrity Let pride, apathy, or judgment rule the room Saint Margaret’s Parking Spot Let me tell you a story. At one of my first churches, there was a beloved senior saint named Margaret. She was known for her fabulous Sunday hats and her warm presence. One Sunday morning, during a business meeting, Margaret made her way to the microphone and said: “There aren’t enough parking spaces for us Senior Adults.” After she explained her concern, our pastor asked: “Margaret, are you making a motion?”
 She answered: 
“I’m making a fuss!” Everyone laughed — but the trustees took her seriously. They doubled the number of Senior-designated parking spots. Margaret was happy. Problem solved. Now, imagine a different reaction: “Margaret, the children of Israel walked for 40 years. You can walk two blocks.”
Or, “Margaret, why don’t you pray to Jesus for contentment and a cheerful spirit?” That would’ve taken a management issue (parking) and tried to fix it with a spiritual response (contentment). And it would’ve backfired — relationally and maybe even spiritually. Misdiagnosed Problems Hurt People Have you ever had a real, tangible concern only to be told you need to adjust your attitude? That’s dismissive. It turns one kind of problem into three. I’ve seen it happen too many times: Someone brings up a practical issue and gets spiritualized into silence. A hurt or offense gets brushed off with “let’s just pray about it.” Mismanagement is labeled as rebellion. Misbehavior is swept under the rug. Before long, staff resign, members drift away, and some even walk away from the faith altogether. It’s like trying to put out fires with lighter fluid .
 No bueno. So What About You? Think about something you’re dealing with right now — at home, at church, or in your circle of influence. What kind of problem is it?
 How are you trying to deal with it? Let’s get practical. ✅ If it’s a management issue... Clarify the process. Adjust the system. Improve the plan. ✅ If it’s a relationship issue... Slow down. Seek to understand. Rebuild trust with empathy. ✅ If it’s a spiritual issue... Pray. Repent. Return to the heart of God and the heart of the matter. A Real-World Example Let’s say a staff member is accused of inappropriate behavior. Good management checks the facts before jumping to conclusions. Good relationship gives people the benefit of the doubt and holds space for both grace and truth. Good spiritual leadership enters with prayerful humility, treating others as you would want to be treated — even in crisis. Missteps compound.
And what starts as one kind of problem can snowball into all three. Reflect + Respond So let me ask you: Can you name the problem? Is it managerial, relational, or spiritual? Are you using the right kind of solution for the kind of problem you're facing? 💡 One of my signature sayings is this: There’s no situation so bad you can’t make it worse. But there’s always time to reconsider the errors of our ways. 🗣️ I’d love to hear your thoughts, stories, or questions. Drop them in the comments below or share this article with someone who’s trying to lead well in the real world. Want more practical wisdom for your leadership journey? Subscribe to my newsletter or explore coaching options for teams and individuals navigating messy, meaningful work.
A group of people including aunt lali and mom
January 27, 2025
“Some friends play at friendship but a true friend sticks closer than one’s nearest kin.” (Proverbs 18:24, NLT) Some friends don’t play games. They’re all-in with you and they’re in it for the long haul. We call them Companions. The Companion is...
A group of people are having a video call.
January 27, 2025
Mike was in a bad place. He was heartbroken after an arduous courtship. Everyone has a story of unrequited love, but Mike’s was unique in that the object of his affections wasn’t a person, but a church. He’d applied for a pastoral position and been...
A picture of debbie downer on a green background
January 27, 2025
Do you remember Debbie Downer, the SNL character famously played by Rachel Dratch? Debbie had a knack for dropping depressing comments while hanging out with her friends. When someone says, “Happy New Year!” Debbie might add, “One year closer to...
A man in a suit is sitting at a desk with a laptop.
January 27, 2025
Leslie Higgins is a man without a desk. When introduced in season one of Ted Lasso, he’s the object of derision for his boss, the butt of endless jokes, a loveable doormat. But in a defining moment, he takes a stand and is a man transformed. Everyone loves an...
A black and white photo of a crowd of people walking down a street.
January 27, 2025
“Do you not know that a leader and a great man has fallen in Israel this day?” (2 Samuel 3:38) I was seven years old when the Reverend Martin Luther King Jr. was assassinated. I’ll never forget the non-stop announcements on the radio in our home. As a little boy in...
Maya angelou is featured on a quarter dollar coin
January 27, 2025
“I’m a woman Phenomenally. Phenomenal woman, That’s me.” – Maya Angelou Today, I present to you the one and only, Maya Angelou. As anxieties about a worldwide pandemic give way to anxieties about the Russian invasion of Ukraine, we can find strength in her...
A black and white photo of a man sitting at a desk using a typewriter
January 24, 2025
“The writer’s job is to tell the truth.” – Ernest Hemingway I’ve been stuck since the new year began. I had a writing rhythm and lost it. Once you lose your stride, it’s hard to regain it. If you feel like a kid who’s fallen off their bike and find it daunting...
A man is sitting at a table with plates of food and wine glasses.
January 24, 2025
“But the fact is, Greg, with the knowledge you’ve been given, you are now on the inside of what I like to call, ‘the Byrnes family circle of trust.’ I keep nothing from you, you keep nothing from me…and round and round we go.” In the...